Hadassah Responds to New York Times Op-Ed on BRCA Gene Testing

Monday, Oct 5 2015

The following Letter to the Editor was published in the NY Times digital edition in response to a mention of Hadassah in an article published on September 25, 2015.

To the Editor:

As a two-time breast cancer survivor, I have nothing but compassion for Elizabeth Wurtzel's situation. However, I was troubled to see how Hadassah's position was characterized.

Earlier this year, Dr. Asher Salmon, an oncologist and deputy director of Hadassah Hospital Ein Kerem in Jerusalem, publicly renounced universal BRCA testing for women starting at age 30. He said that the results of BRCA testing alone, without genetic counseling and extensive analysis of family history, do not provide women with the complete picture needed to make an intelligent decision regarding treatment.

"Women with a family history of breast cancer should be tested — maybe as early as age 25 — but the majority of women never have to be tested," said Dr. Salmon. "We shouldn't be practicing one-size-fits-all medicine, but rather medicine with appropriate protocols, guidelines and individualized treatment based on patients' personal histories."

Dr. Salmon's positions represent the consensus in the medical industry. Hadassah believes one thing above all: Choosing a breast cancer screening is a decision that should be made on the basis of science, family history and the informed views of experts.

New York

The writer is national president of Hadassah, the Women’s Zionist Organization of America.


Read the full published responses.


No comments yet.
First Name
Enter this word:

Related Stories


Wednesday, Oct 19 2016

Watch Hadassah on the Today Show!

Three Hadassah members brought Today Show host Kathie Lee Gifford to tears on air early Wednesday morning as they shared their moving story about their battle with breast cancer, the BRCA1 gene mutation and making the decision to get genetic testing.


Wednesday, Sep 28 2016

Hadassah Multidisciplinary Team Restores Little Girl’s Hands and Legs

Six-year-old Ruthie Rosenthal, who suffered paralysis of her hands and legs after a fall, is now up and walking, thanks to innovative back surgery by the Hadassah Medical Organization’s team of multidisciplinary specialists.


Wednesday, Sep 28 2016

To Our Soldiers With Love: Bravo Hadassah International Israel!

In a tribute to Israel’s soldiers and terror survivors, 2400 men and women attended a Gala event on September 14th, conceived and executed by Hadassah International Israel (HII) to raise funds for the Rehabilitation Department at Hadassah Mount Scopus.


Tuesday, Sep 27 2016

Maryland Governor Larry Hogan Pledges Expanded Cooperation with Hadassah

Maryland Governor Lawrence Joseph "Larry" Hogan, Jr. pledged expanded cooperation with Hadassah Medical Organization during his visit WHEN, which included a symposium on new approaches to treating cancer, visits to children with cancer, and a tour of HMO's shock trauma center, patterned after one at the University of Maryland.   


Contact Us

40 Wall Street

New York, NY 10005


More ›

Membership Questions


(800) 664-5646

Donation Questions


(800) 928-0685

Missions Department


(800) 237-1517

Show More