|
Words
can be as powerful as weapons, and Israels current
struggle is being waged as fiercely on television as it
is on the battlefield. As a result, a new brand of leader
is taking her place in the upper ranks of the Israel Defense
Forces: Colonel Miri Eisen, 40, is one of Israels
most effective weapons in the media war. Eisen was plucked
last March from the ranks of the IDF Intelligence Corps
after demonstrating a unique talent at explaining and persuading.
Officially, her current title is head of doctrine in the
IDFs Combat Intelligence Corps. She is thought of
so highly as a spokeswoman that last spring, when a terrorist
attack caused Prime Minister Ariel Sharon to cancel a briefing
before the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish
Organizations in New York, Eisen was the choice to stand
in for him. By all accounts, she dazzled those who attended.
With her attractive appearance, her charismatic presence
and her ability to communicate effectively in both Hebrew
and English, Eisen was immediately dubbed a new star
on the hasbara horizon in The Jerusalem
Post.
At the
presidents conference, eisen allowed herself only
one personal comment. Yes, I was born here,
she told the American audience. My parents made aliya
31 years ago. I know I sound very American but Im
a full colonel in Israeli intelligence. She then proceeded,
rapid-fire, to review the documents captured by Israeli
troops during their West Bank incursions in March and April,
including those showing Saudi Arabian money that went to
the families of suicide bombers. She compared it to documents
that some donors to Israeli causes might see that indicates
where their contributions have gone.
She also took on one of the myths about terrorism that even
some of those closest to Israel believe. Theres
one that President Bush [expressed] yesterday, Eisen
allowed. Theres a myth that terrorism is something
that poor people do because they are under occupation and
they wake up in the morning and go out and miraculously
find weapons in the backyard and then, just as miraculously
they suddenly walk onto the third floor of a pool club in
Rishon Lezion and explode. She then examined the complex
infrastructure of terrorism, which involves what she calls
four legsideology, people, weapons and
money.
If the atmosphere in New York was a combination of businesslike
and heimish, Eisens main outreachfor
which she tends to speak more slowly and deliberatelyis
with the media. Placing an intelligence officer in front
of the cameras was clearly a sign that the Israeli government
and military were worried enough to take an unconventional
step, says Gerald Steinberg, a political studies professor
at Bar-Ilan University and senior research associate at
the BESA (Begin-Sadat) Center for Strategic Studies.
It was an unusual move, and probably should have been
done much earlier, Steinberg comments. Not to
be cute, but people who serve in intelligence positions
are usually quite intelligent.
Steinberg
gives eisen high marks. Shes articulate, she
has a depth of knowledge, and she knows how to pitch her
responses in an intelligent way to suit different audiences,
he asserts. Certainly in Jenin, she was able to calmly
explain the Israeli position without becoming aggressive
and hostile. She is very different in her approach than
previous Israeli spokespeople, particularly in her facial
expressions; she does not frown or reveal disregard or dislike
for those questioning her. Also, you cant deny that
being a woman makes a difference. Shes the antithesis
of the gruff male military officer.
But this new star is uncomfortable in the spotlight. After
all, for someone in military intelligence, public exposure,
particularly on television, is a career drawback. Colonel
Eisen doesnt consider herself the story, was
the message delivered by the IDF spokesmans office
when declining a request for an interview for this article.
Eisen has, in fact, refused all requests for interviews
outside the setting of military briefings or television
interviews regarding a specific military action.
While Eisen dislikes talking about herself to the press,
she is front and center when it comes to articulating Israels
case to the world. Her biggest test took place when Israel
was being sharply criticized for its incursions in the West
Bank last spring during Operation Defensive Shield, particularly
in Jenin, where the Palestinians were accusing the IDF of
a massacre. Eisen stood in Jenin as CNN correspondent Christiane
Amanpour lobbed tough questions at her regarding the Jenin
operation and why Israel bulldozed the homes in the refugee
camps.
Its difficult to appreciate Eisens talent without
actually seeing it in actionher cool and her ability
to change the agenda when responding to a loaded question.
Calm in the face of pressure, Eisen told Amanpour that the
houses had to be destroyed because some of them were booby
trapped. When I say booby traps, I am talking about
explosives within the structures, surrounding the structures,
she said into the face of the camera. We found them
inside refrigerators, along the road. Thats the reason
the structures were knocked down.
And why did Israeli troops prevent ambulances from heading
into Jenin to evacuate the wounded, Amanpour asked. Eisen
replied, We were stopping ambulances along the way,
and checking them, not [barring] them into the camp
.
It was because of this we found within those ambulances
terrorists explosives, a very cynical use of ambulances.
Her job was not easy, given the images of devastated homes
being broadcast. Time after time, she emphasized that Israel
had done what was logistically more difficult but more humane
in raiding the densely populated areas in search of terrorists
on the ground instead of from the air. What would
have been easier than to go in without any of the officers
or infantry soldiers killed there and bomb with an F-16?
she asked. We didnt do so.
Eisen continually reminded CNN viewers and the rest of the
world press the West Bank operations did not take place
in a vacuum, but to prevent more suicide attacks. The
more we find terrorists, arrest them, find the explosives
and find the people, [the] less suicide bombers in our cities,
she told reporters.
She was equally adept when an Australian Broadcasting Corporation
reporter grilled her about reports of abusive behavior by
IDF soldiers at Israeli checkpoints in which Palestinians
were forced to undress in a humiliating fashion.
Have you ever seen a suicide belt? replied Eisen.
I could wear [one] underneath this shirt. All youd
see was that I was wearing some type of a vest. Inside the
veststitched inare lines of explosives. When
you put them on, all it looks like is its an overweight
person. Sadly, theres no other way to check
.
[Its] something thats beyond my cultural grasp,
but the fact is that its human beings who dress themselves
in a suicide belt and they have to get through these checkpoints
to be able to get to the center of Israel. Thats how
they explode.
In another instance after accusations of a massacre in Jenin,
Eisen showed reporters a scene caught on video by an Israeli
drone flying over the town. Palestinians were filming a
staged funeral, she pointed out, to use in misleading researchers
sent to investigate the alleged massacre. Pallbearers carried
a body wrapped in a blanket, which was indeed a man pretending
to be dead; the corpse kept jumping out of the
blanket. Some of the press present at the demonstration
had a hard time surpressing their giggles. The United Nations
later found the massacre allegations to be false.
Says Steinberg, Many spokespeople fall into the traps
laid by the press. They create an agenda of Palestinian
victimization and Israelis [are put] on the defensive. A
good spokesperson like Eisen knows how to avoid this trap,
putting the onus and the burden on the other side, but doing
it sincerely and not artificially, in excellent English.
Born
in san francisco, eisen immigrated to Israel with her family
in 1971 when she was 9 years old. She entered the army in
1980, serving in the intelligence unit that focused on the
area she would come to specialize in: the Arab world. After
she completed her service, she pursued a degree in political
science and Middle Eastern studies at Tel-Aviv University.
Then she rejoined the IDF as a career intelligence officer.
Eisen came to the attention of Ehud Barak on his first day
as IDF commander-in-chief when terrorists struck a kibbutz
on the countrys northern border. She was in charge
of briefing Barakand clearly she made an impression.
Two weeks later Barak put her on his personal staff.
She returned to intelligence in 1994, and two years later
she went to work for General Moshe Yaalon, then head
of military intelligence and today the IDF chief of staff.
It was after serving in other senior intelligence positions
that Eisen was placed in the media glare.
Eisenwho lives with her husband and two small children
in Tel Avivis one of a group of women in the IDF,
including newly appointed army spokeswoman Ruth Yaron, who
are trying to change the image of the Israeli military.
Given her collegial relationship with Yaalon, those
who know the army well say that Eisen herself is likely
to enjoy further promotion, which will enhance the visibility
and the status of women even more.
In her speeches and press appearances, Eisen describes the
ideology and hatred that fuel the terrorist campaign against
Israel. In an April military briefing to a large group of
reporters, she described the schools in Jenin, Ramallah,
Bethlehem, Kalkilya and Tulkarm in which the walls were
plastered with the posters of the glorification
of suicide bombers, and said that the contents of textbooks
found there represented an education deep in hatred,
which has violence as an integral part.
As a civil person in Israel, aside from being a military
person, all I can say is that to me the most horrific part
of what we have seen is the depth of hatred and the education
to violence, which has nothing to do with occupation,
she declared. It has everything to do with what you
say. If you dont recognize the State of Israel [under
any circumstances], the seeds of violence are very easy.
She also noted that in the office of one of Arafats
bodyguards Israeli soldiers found books denying the Holocaust
and every possible anti-Semitic horrific thing that
you can think of from the last 100 years. She emphasizes
that It is a book that was printed [by] the PA, sent
to their office and we found it on the shelves there.
She challenged the press to find equivalent hate on the
Israeli side.
While she refuses to discuss her personal life for public
consumption, Eisen does occasionally invoke it in order
to make her case. When a reporter asked her whether, as
an IDF officer, she was worried about the future, she didnt
hesitate. I worry as a mother more than as a military
person, she said.
|