Hadassah

Hadassah Responds to New York Times Op-Ed on BRCA Gene Testing

Monday, Oct 5 2015

The following Letter to the Editor was published in the NY Times digital edition in response to a mention of Hadassah in an article published on September 25, 2015.

To the Editor:

As a two-time breast cancer survivor, I have nothing but compassion for Elizabeth Wurtzel's situation. However, I was troubled to see how Hadassah's position was characterized.

Earlier this year, Dr. Asher Salmon, an oncologist and deputy director of Hadassah Hospital Ein Kerem in Jerusalem, publicly renounced universal BRCA testing for women starting at age 30. He said that the results of BRCA testing alone, without genetic counseling and extensive analysis of family history, do not provide women with the complete picture needed to make an intelligent decision regarding treatment.

"Women with a family history of breast cancer should be tested — maybe as early as age 25 — but the majority of women never have to be tested," said Dr. Salmon. "We shouldn't be practicing one-size-fits-all medicine, but rather medicine with appropriate protocols, guidelines and individualized treatment based on patients' personal histories."

Dr. Salmon's positions represent the consensus in the medical industry. Hadassah believes one thing above all: Choosing a breast cancer screening is a decision that should be made on the basis of science, family history and the informed views of experts.

MARCIE NATAN
New York

The writer is national president of Hadassah, the Women’s Zionist Organization of America.

 

Read the full published responses.

Related Stories

alt_text

Monday, Mar 16 2020

Pregnant Woman Was in Quarantine. Then She Went into Labor.

When the staff at Hadassah Hospital Ein Kerem got the heads up from the Magen David Adom ambulance team that Sara*, a quarantined patient they were transporting, was in labor, they rushed into action to prepare and equip a special delivery facility for the potentially infectious mother-to-be.

READ MORE ›
alt_text

Wednesday, Mar 11 2020

Talia Liben Yarmush - The Blessings and Trauma of IVF

Ultimately, IVF is much like a difficult birth. If you remembered all the pain, you’d be hard-pressed to do it again...

READ MORE ›
alt_text

Wednesday, Mar 11 2020

Hadassah Members Share Their Struggles to Become Mothers

As part of Hadassah’s larger efforts to decrease stigma around infertility, the magazine is sharing stories of adoption as...

READ MORE ›
alt_text

Wednesday, Mar 11 2020

Rachel Halperin-Zibelman - Learning to Live My Best Life Without Children

I asked myself whether we could attempt to be a “family” without children? Had we only gotten married to procreate?

READ MORE ›

Donation Questions

donorservices@hadassah.org

(800) 928-0685

Membership Questions

membership@hadassah.org

(800) 664-5646

Israel Travel

israeltravel@hadassah.org

(800) 237-1517

Contact Us

40 Wall Street

New York, NY 10005

support@hadassah.org

More ›

Show More